The Bagel Shop in North Cape May, NJ serves authentic NY-style bagels and locally roasted Bean2Bean Coffee in a family-owned, community-focused setting.
The Bagel Shop in North Cape May proudly serves Bean2Bean Coffee! Located at 3845 Bayshore Road in the ACME Shopping Center, this family-owned shop has been a staple in the community for over five generations. Known for their authentic New York-style bagels—boiled and baked on burlap for that perfect texture—The Bagel Shop offers a variety of bagels, homemade cream cheeses, deli salads, and sandwiches. Guests can pair their favorite bagel or sandwich with freshly brewed Bean2Bean Coffee, roasted locally for bold flavor and smooth balance. Whether you're enjoying a classic egg and cheese bagel sandwich or a smoked Nova special, The Bagel Shop provides a welcoming atmosphere to start your day right.
